Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Catholic Religion and Euthanasia
Catholic teaching condemns euthanasia as a "crime against life". The teaching of the Catholic Church on euthanasia rests on several core principles of Catholic ethics, including the sanctity of human life, the dignity of the human person, concomitant human rights, due proportionality in casuistic remedies, the unavoidability of death, and the importance of charity. The Church's official position is the 1980 Declaration on Euthanasia issued by the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith.
In Catholic medical ethics official pronouncements strongly oppose active euthanasia, whether voluntary or not, while allowing dying to proceed without medical interventions that would be considered "extraordinary" or "disproportionate."
In Catholic medical ethics official pronouncements strongly oppose active euthanasia, whether voluntary or not, while allowing dying to proceed without medical interventions that would be considered "extraordinary" or "disproportionate."
Euthanasia and the Law
During the 20th Century, efforts to change government policies on euthanasia in the 20th century have met limited success in Western countries. Euthanasia policies have been developed by a variety of NGOs, most notably medical associations and advocacy organizations.
Euthanasia is illegal in most of the United States. Attempts to legalize euthanasia and assisted suicide resulted in ballot initiatives and "legislation bills" within the United States of America in the last 20 years. For example, Washington voters saw Ballot Initiative 1119 in 1991, California placed Proposition 161 on the ballot in 1992, Oregon passed the Death with Dignity Act in 1997, Michigan included Proposal B in their ballot in 1998, and Washington's Initiative 1000 on the ballot in 2008.
Euthanasia is illegal in most of the United States. Attempts to legalize euthanasia and assisted suicide resulted in ballot initiatives and "legislation bills" within the United States of America in the last 20 years. For example, Washington voters saw Ballot Initiative 1119 in 1991, California placed Proposition 161 on the ballot in 1992, Oregon passed the Death with Dignity Act in 1997, Michigan included Proposal B in their ballot in 1998, and Washington's Initiative 1000 on the ballot in 2008.
Early History of Euthanasia
The term euthanasia comes from the Greek words "eu"-meaning good and "thanatos"-meaning death, which combined means “well-death” or "dying well". Hippocrates mentions euthanasia in the Hippocratic oath, written between 400 and 300 B.C. The original Oath states: “To please no one will I prescribe a deadly drug nor give advice which may cause his death." Despite this, the ancient Greeks and Romans generally did not believe that life needed to be preserved at any cost and were, in consequence, tolerant of suicide in cases where no relief could be offered to the dying or where a person no longer cared for his life.
Monday, December 8, 2008
Wikipedia Experience
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Euthanasia&action=submit
I think it's a very good point you bring up that euthanasia is obviously to end one's suffering, but what about times where ending one's suffering was not ther decision? Like if a family member decides to have a doctor take you off life support, but you didn't ultimately want to be taken off life support (but did not have the ability to tell your family member what you truly wanted); how can someone really decide when and how one's suffering should end? I do not believe this is a legal question, involing injection and what not, but more of a moral issue, the deepest issue to face when dealing with euthanasia. [[User:KcutieKcutie]] ([[User talk:Kcutietalk]]) 21:28, 8 December 2008 (UTC)
It has not been deleted or commented on yet, but I do not think it will be bothered much because it was more of a comment rather than changing any information. I think editing Wikipedia can be useful and interesting to people who have a deep knowledge about the subject, but I feel wrong almost completely changing/modifying other peoples thoughts/opinions/facts. Also, the Wikipedia editing was slightly confusing (with codes and such), so it may be easier for people who do this on a regular basis.
I think it's a very good point you bring up that euthanasia is obviously to end one's suffering, but what about times where ending one's suffering was not ther decision? Like if a family member decides to have a doctor take you off life support, but you didn't ultimately want to be taken off life support (but did not have the ability to tell your family member what you truly wanted); how can someone really decide when and how one's suffering should end? I do not believe this is a legal question, involing injection and what not, but more of a moral issue, the deepest issue to face when dealing with euthanasia. [[User:KcutieKcutie]] ([[User talk:Kcutietalk]]) 21:28, 8 December 2008 (UTC)
It has not been deleted or commented on yet, but I do not think it will be bothered much because it was more of a comment rather than changing any information. I think editing Wikipedia can be useful and interesting to people who have a deep knowledge about the subject, but I feel wrong almost completely changing/modifying other peoples thoughts/opinions/facts. Also, the Wikipedia editing was slightly confusing (with codes and such), so it may be easier for people who do this on a regular basis.
Tuesday, November 18, 2008
Quick Facts
Some quick facts (history, definitions...) on euthanasia and physician assisted suicide.
FACT #1: The earliest American statute explicitly to outlaw assisting suicide was enacted in New York in 1828
FACT #2: In 1998 U.S. state of Oregon legalizes assisted suicide
FACT #3: Euthanasia by omission is intentionally causing death by not providing necessary and ordinary (usual and customary) care or food and water
FACT #4: Physician assisted suicide is NOT the same as euthanasia
FACT #5: Euthanasia can be conducted either voluntary (with consent) or involuntary (without consent)
FACT #6: The term euthanasia comes from the Greek words "eu"-meaning good and "thanatos"-meaning death
FACT #7: Dr. Jack Kevorkian was a Michigan physician infamous for encouraging and assisting people in committing suicide which resulted in a Michigan law against the practice in 1992
FACT #8: Perhaps the strongest argument made on behalf of legalizing euthanasia or assisted suicide is that it, like abortion, it is a "choice" issue
FACT #9: “I will give no deadly medicine to any one if asked, nor suggest any such counsel” ---The Hippocratic Oath
FACT #10: Although euthanasia and assisted suicide are illegal in Switzerland, assisted suicide is penalized only if it is carried out "from selfish motives."
FACT #1: The earliest American statute explicitly to outlaw assisting suicide was enacted in New York in 1828
FACT #2: In 1998 U.S. state of Oregon legalizes assisted suicide
FACT #3: Euthanasia by omission is intentionally causing death by not providing necessary and ordinary (usual and customary) care or food and water
FACT #4: Physician assisted suicide is NOT the same as euthanasia
FACT #5: Euthanasia can be conducted either voluntary (with consent) or involuntary (without consent)
FACT #6: The term euthanasia comes from the Greek words "eu"-meaning good and "thanatos"-meaning death
FACT #7: Dr. Jack Kevorkian was a Michigan physician infamous for encouraging and assisting people in committing suicide which resulted in a Michigan law against the practice in 1992
FACT #8: Perhaps the strongest argument made on behalf of legalizing euthanasia or assisted suicide is that it, like abortion, it is a "choice" issue
FACT #9: “I will give no deadly medicine to any one if asked, nor suggest any such counsel” ---The Hippocratic Oath
FACT #10: Although euthanasia and assisted suicide are illegal in Switzerland, assisted suicide is penalized only if it is carried out "from selfish motives."
Sunday, November 16, 2008
YouTube Video
Euthanasia - our right to choose the time to die
This was an interesting video because it gives the argument(s) for why voluntary euthanasia should be a right and legalized. The speaker has experienced the pain of losing someone, and she expresses how difficult it was losing her family member in such a painful way. The video discusses since we all have the right to life, we should all have the right to decide our time to die, and when/how we choose to do it. I think this video obviously shows how hard it is for family members to watch loved one's live in pain and then to suffer, and why it would morally and emotionally make sense to legalize euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. After watching the pro's of legalizing these practices, it would be interesting to find a video where someone discussed the con's of the practices (perhaps telling a personal experience where euthanasia was performed and had a negative outcome).
This was an interesting video because it gives the argument(s) for why voluntary euthanasia should be a right and legalized. The speaker has experienced the pain of losing someone, and she expresses how difficult it was losing her family member in such a painful way. The video discusses since we all have the right to life, we should all have the right to decide our time to die, and when/how we choose to do it. I think this video obviously shows how hard it is for family members to watch loved one's live in pain and then to suffer, and why it would morally and emotionally make sense to legalize euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. After watching the pro's of legalizing these practices, it would be interesting to find a video where someone discussed the con's of the practices (perhaps telling a personal experience where euthanasia was performed and had a negative outcome).
Friday, November 14, 2008
Interlibrary Loan Request
"Euthanasia: The Moral Issues" by Robert M. Baird and Stuart E. Rosenbaum
Although the book discusses how euthanasia and physician assisted suicide has affected society (and individuals) in a more positive way, it also mentions the "wrongfulness" these practices may bring. When discussing the wrongfulness (chapter 11), the book focuses on arguments from three perspectives: nature, self-interest, and practical effects. I found these arguments to be interesting and slightly different from other "negative effects" other authors have talked about referring to euthanasia/physician assisted suicide.
Argument from nature: The argument says that euthanasia does violence to the natural goal of survival (the natural inclination to continue living). Euthanasia is "literally acting against nature because all the processes of nature are bent towards the end of bodily and survival and euthanasia defeats these subtle mechanisms in a way that disease and injury might not." I feel as though this argument does make sense, but should not be considered in all cases. Although our body gives natural signs to fight back to survive, a patient may be in too much pain and feel too defeated to continue to try and "fight." The argument should not be made in a situation where the patient may suffer severe critical pain and agony by trying to stay alive, rather than going through with the euthanasia process.
Argument from self-interest: This argument basically says that a decision such as euthanasia would result in final choices; the decision to die would result in death, which is not irreversible and cannot simply be undone. A mistaken diagnosis can be made, and a patient can act on the wrong symptoms given to them. This basically means that many people should not follow the practice of euthanasia/physician assisted suicide because the diagnosis they are acting on may be incorrect, and their self-interest is at stake. If the case is that an incorrect diagnosis is made, or is more than likely incorrect, I do feel this is a valid argument. In most cases, I do not feel that it is the strongest of arguments. In most, if not all cases, medical decisions are not made without research and time. Also, patients considering euthanasia would appear to have an obvious disease or problem, which would most likely mean that the diagnosis is correct. Today, the act of euthanasia and physician assisted suicide has many rules and regulations before actually being performed, so it is too hard to act suddenly on impulse or concern (which the argument is saying patients do).
Argument from practical effects: This argument follows the thought that euthanasia as a policy is a slipper slope. The book says "it could have a corrupting influencce so that in any case that is sever doctors and nurses might not try hard enough to save the patient." If doctors do not take the necessary steps to save one's life because they would just be "better off dead" would result in an overall decline in the quality of medical care. It is argued to be a slipper slope because euthanasia would first be done voluntary, then made directed, then finally to involuntary. Many psychiatrists feel these steps could lead to several "mental" problems being mistaken for medical problems (letting euthanasia and physician assisted suicide available to patients that do not 'really' need it, but just 'think' they do). This argument seems too unrealistic in my opinion because nobody can decide the future of how these practices will turn out; nobody can say that the slipper slop theory will happen for sure. I do agree that there are dangers in legalizing euthanasia and physician assisted suicide, but I do believe that precautions can be made and that allowing the practices could overall benefit many.
I do feel these are valid arguments in some cases, and I can understand why some people believe in these arguments (and these are reasons why they don't agree with euthanasia and physician assisted suicide). However, they have not convinced me enough to change my entire view on these medical practices, which is a more pro-choice stance.
I do feel these are valid arguments in some cases, and I can understand why some people believe in these arguments (and these are reasons why they don't agree with euthanasia and physician assisted suicide). However, they have not convinced me enough to change my entire view on these medical practices, which is a more pro-choice stance.
QUIZ
Here is a short quiz on basic euthanasia and physician assisted suicide facts. All answers can be found at medical websites, informational websites/books, legal articles, and also in past posts on this blog.
1. Which state has a (form) of legalized euthanasia?
a. New York
b. Oregon
c. Colorado
d. Rhode Island
2. What kind of consent can euthanasia be issued?
a. Voluntary euthanasia (with consent)
b. Involuntary euthanasia (without consent)
c. No such thing
d. a and b
3. How can euthanasia be conducted?
a. Passively
b. Non-actively
c. Actively
d. a, b, and c
4. What does non-active euthanasia mean?
a. Doctor refuses to treat patient
b. Not a way to be conducted
c. Doctor withdraws life-support
d. Patient runs away from hospital
5. What is the loose tranlastion of euthanasia?
a. "well-death"
b. "young-death"
c. "pain-be-gone"
d. "patient-killing"
6. Is euthanasia and physician assisted suicide exactly the same?
a. Yes; the doctor acts directly in both
b. No; the patient administers the medication in physician assisted suicide
c. They are exactly the same
d. Depends on the doctor
7. On cases such as euthanasia and abortion, Obama is more "pro-choice" and McCain is more "pro-life"
a. False
b. True
8. Oregon has issued a "Death with _______ Act"
a. Compassion
b. Medicine
c. Dignity
d. Oregon has issued no act concerning euthanasia/physician assisted suicide
9. What is "the practice of sedating a terminally ill competent patient to the point of unconsciousness, then allowing the patient to die of her disease, starvation, or dehydration"?
a. Doctor sedation
b. Life-sustaining method
c. Termanation
d. Terminal sedation
10. When was euthanasia first mentioned (whether 'for' or 'against')?
a. The U.S. Constitution
b. Egyption scriptures
c. The Hippocratic Oath
d. English Common Law
1. Which state has a (form) of legalized euthanasia?
a. New York
b. Oregon
c. Colorado
d. Rhode Island
2. What kind of consent can euthanasia be issued?
a. Voluntary euthanasia (with consent)
b. Involuntary euthanasia (without consent)
c. No such thing
d. a and b
3. How can euthanasia be conducted?
a. Passively
b. Non-actively
c. Actively
d. a, b, and c
4. What does non-active euthanasia mean?
a. Doctor refuses to treat patient
b. Not a way to be conducted
c. Doctor withdraws life-support
d. Patient runs away from hospital
5. What is the loose tranlastion of euthanasia?
a. "well-death"
b. "young-death"
c. "pain-be-gone"
d. "patient-killing"
6. Is euthanasia and physician assisted suicide exactly the same?
a. Yes; the doctor acts directly in both
b. No; the patient administers the medication in physician assisted suicide
c. They are exactly the same
d. Depends on the doctor
7. On cases such as euthanasia and abortion, Obama is more "pro-choice" and McCain is more "pro-life"
a. False
b. True
8. Oregon has issued a "Death with _______ Act"
a. Compassion
b. Medicine
c. Dignity
d. Oregon has issued no act concerning euthanasia/physician assisted suicide
9. What is "the practice of sedating a terminally ill competent patient to the point of unconsciousness, then allowing the patient to die of her disease, starvation, or dehydration"?
a. Doctor sedation
b. Life-sustaining method
c. Termanation
d. Terminal sedation
10. When was euthanasia first mentioned (whether 'for' or 'against')?
a. The U.S. Constitution
b. Egyption scriptures
c. The Hippocratic Oath
d. English Common Law
Tuesday, November 11, 2008
Question for student...
Question posted on http://said-k.blogspot.com/
Kcutie said...
It is clear to see that Obama is for allowing the practice of abortion to be legal, and that McCain wants abortion to be banned. However, both seem to agree that a marriage should be between a man and a woman, not people of the same sex. With the different views on abortion, but similar views on marriage, would it still be safe to safe Obama is strictly pro-choice and McCain is strictly pro-life (following mainly the abortion case)? What other situations do you think Obama would consider that McCain would be strongly against?
One thing I learned from this blog was the basis behind the Unruh Civil Rights Act. After a lesbian was denied fertality treatments at North Coast Women's Care Medical Group, she argued in the Supreme Court that the center had violated her rights to receive treatment because of her sexual orientation. The Supreme Court agreed with the women, and said the center must follow the Unruh Civil Rights Act, “in ensuring full and equal access to medical treatment irrespective of sexual orientation, including a right to full medical assistance in establishing a pregnancy.”
Kcutie said...
It is clear to see that Obama is for allowing the practice of abortion to be legal, and that McCain wants abortion to be banned. However, both seem to agree that a marriage should be between a man and a woman, not people of the same sex. With the different views on abortion, but similar views on marriage, would it still be safe to safe Obama is strictly pro-choice and McCain is strictly pro-life (following mainly the abortion case)? What other situations do you think Obama would consider that McCain would be strongly against?
One thing I learned from this blog was the basis behind the Unruh Civil Rights Act. After a lesbian was denied fertality treatments at North Coast Women's Care Medical Group, she argued in the Supreme Court that the center had violated her rights to receive treatment because of her sexual orientation. The Supreme Court agreed with the women, and said the center must follow the Unruh Civil Rights Act, “in ensuring full and equal access to medical treatment irrespective of sexual orientation, including a right to full medical assistance in establishing a pregnancy.”
Monday, November 10, 2008
Itunes U Podcast
Title: Physician Assisted Suicide: An Analysis of U.S. Supreme Court Precedent
(Bioethics Grand Round)
Author/Speaker: Stewart Albertson
This speech was focused in California, discussing the "California Compassionate Act" that follows the Oregon Death with Dignity act concerning physician assisted suicide. Stewart Albertson talks about understanding the distinction between fundamental rights and ordinary rights under the U.S. Constitution's 14th Amendment substantive due process clause, how physician assisted suicide fits in to Supreme Courts interpretation on what is and what is not a protected fundamental right, and the issue of federalism (the sharing of concurring power between the federal state and local governments). Albertson also discusses the case of Gonzalez v Oregon and how that will impact California's own physician assisted legislation. Albertson also compares the issues with physician assisted suicide with the case in Griswold v Connecticut. This speech is very useful for those interested in learning more about physician assisted suicide because it gives the legal perspective on the issue. It explains how the constitution, federal government, and previous rulings all tie into the matter of physician assisted suicide [especially state to state]. Albertons talks about past issues in this area and how they have been resolved, how the constitution discusses (or does not discuss) this matter, and the power each state has in deciding what laws to allow concerning physician assisted suicide.
An interesting fact(s) that I learned from this podcast dealt with the power that the federal government and states have on certain policies (or don't have in several cases). The states want to retain certain powers; the power that deals with physician assisted suicide is the general police power, which means the state has the right to regulate the health safety and wealthfare of it's citizenry. With physician assisted suicide, the federal government cannot come in and tell the state what they can and cannot do in this area. This is why different states have different laws/regulations/acts concering physician assisted suicide; some may decide that the practice is okay (such as Oregon) and some may decide to put [law] restrictions on allowing physician assisted suicide (such as several states have done).
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
Comment on blog...
http://www.pallimed.org/2008/10/physician-assisted-suicide-vote-in.html
This blog talked about Washington introducing a new "death with dignity" measure to be decided upon [relating to the post previously posted]. With the election being today, I was wondering how, or if, others thought new proposals (and existing one's such as Oregon's case) discussing euthanasia/physician assisted suicide may pursuade voters.
Kcutie said...
Do you have any comments or feelings about the current Oregon "death with dignity act?" With the election upon us, it is clear that Obama is pro-choice and McCain is pro-life; does this influence your [or do you think it influences others] reason to vote for one or the other candidate? Obama has said that the decision he had made on the Schiavo case [to continue with the euthanasia process] was the worst choice he has ever made, could that also have an effect over how people may vote?
November 04, 2008
This blog talked about Washington introducing a new "death with dignity" measure to be decided upon [relating to the post previously posted]. With the election being today, I was wondering how, or if, others thought new proposals (and existing one's such as Oregon's case) discussing euthanasia/physician assisted suicide may pursuade voters.
Kcutie said...
Do you have any comments or feelings about the current Oregon "death with dignity act?" With the election upon us, it is clear that Obama is pro-choice and McCain is pro-life; does this influence your [or do you think it influences others] reason to vote for one or the other candidate? Obama has said that the decision he had made on the Schiavo case [to continue with the euthanasia process] was the worst choice he has ever made, could that also have an effect over how people may vote?
November 04, 2008
Monday, November 3, 2008
Law.com Response
http://www.law.com/jsp/pa/PubArticlePA.jsp?id=1202425218745
The article "Washington weighs lethal meds for terminally ill"discusses that Washington state voters are currently deciding whether to allow doctors to prescribe lethal medication to the terminally ill. The measure would specifically allow physicians in Washington [state] to help terminally ill patients end their lives (the same law Oregon approved in 1994). Between advertisements from both sides (people who support the euthanasia/physician assisted suicide movement and people who do not support the act), $3.5 million has been generated.
The new information I found interesting in this article are the statistics given for people supporting/opposing the measure. Although I tend to be more in favor of physician assisted suicide for terminally ill patients, I had assumed that many others would not want such laws like Oregon's to be made (considering many other states have not adopted the law). An independent pollster found that 57% of voters polled supported Washington's measure, 33% opposed, and only 10% undecided. From the same poll, conducted in September, 16% were leaning towards 'yes' and 10% leaning towards 'no'. I was surprised to see more than 50% had supported the measure, and even more voters were leaning towards 'yes' rather than 'no'.
The article also mentions how "there is that libertarian streak in the northwest..." which may explain why Washington state feels very similar as Oregon on the new measure.
Washington's new proposal is different this time in it that it "would not allow doctors to administer lethal drugs on behalf of patients who couldn't do so themselves."
Considering this article is overall pro-physician assisted suicide, and that I am more pro-choice on patients making medical decisions, it has not changed my mind on any type of views or opinions I have on euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. I feel as though Washington, and Oregon as well, is not looking at allowing physician-assisted suicide to be taken as a bad thing, but rather to help the terminally ill and decrease suffering in their lives. Like the article mentions, this new measure will not be done "on whim" and many precautions and considerations will be made for each terminally ill patient and their decision. If anything, this article makes my feelings toward euthanasia and physician assisted suicide stronger, because having this option(s) creates more of a freedom and a choice for people who are truly in pain and suffering. I feel as though the United States is about freedom and being "free", including pain-free.
The article "Washington weighs lethal meds for terminally ill"discusses that Washington state voters are currently deciding whether to allow doctors to prescribe lethal medication to the terminally ill. The measure would specifically allow physicians in Washington [state] to help terminally ill patients end their lives (the same law Oregon approved in 1994). Between advertisements from both sides (people who support the euthanasia/physician assisted suicide movement and people who do not support the act), $3.5 million has been generated.
The new information I found interesting in this article are the statistics given for people supporting/opposing the measure. Although I tend to be more in favor of physician assisted suicide for terminally ill patients, I had assumed that many others would not want such laws like Oregon's to be made (considering many other states have not adopted the law). An independent pollster found that 57% of voters polled supported Washington's measure, 33% opposed, and only 10% undecided. From the same poll, conducted in September, 16% were leaning towards 'yes' and 10% leaning towards 'no'. I was surprised to see more than 50% had supported the measure, and even more voters were leaning towards 'yes' rather than 'no'.
The article also mentions how "there is that libertarian streak in the northwest..." which may explain why Washington state feels very similar as Oregon on the new measure.
Washington's new proposal is different this time in it that it "would not allow doctors to administer lethal drugs on behalf of patients who couldn't do so themselves."
Considering this article is overall pro-physician assisted suicide, and that I am more pro-choice on patients making medical decisions, it has not changed my mind on any type of views or opinions I have on euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. I feel as though Washington, and Oregon as well, is not looking at allowing physician-assisted suicide to be taken as a bad thing, but rather to help the terminally ill and decrease suffering in their lives. Like the article mentions, this new measure will not be done "on whim" and many precautions and considerations will be made for each terminally ill patient and their decision. If anything, this article makes my feelings toward euthanasia and physician assisted suicide stronger, because having this option(s) creates more of a freedom and a choice for people who are truly in pain and suffering. I feel as though the United States is about freedom and being "free", including pain-free.
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
My Position
My personal position and opinions on euthanasia and physician assisted suicide are very similar to the one's of Barack Obama and Joe Biden. Just like the two Democrats, I do believe that everyone should be allowed to make their own decisions, in majority [if not all] cases. Furthermore, I am not stating that I am FOR euthanasia and physician assisted suicide [like Obama and Biden have claimed]; I am simply FOR allowing American's to have a choice on what they would like to do. I believe that the United States is deemed "land of the free" for a reason, and creating restrictions on these citizens would take away from this "freedom." Like the Democratic party, I do have a more pro-choice attitude towards acts such as abortion and euthanasia. However, I have created this position before Obama's recent statements over the Terri Schiavo case. I give John McCain credit for stating his pro-life position early on and consistently keeping a pro-life attitude throughout this campaign. While I have more similar feelings toward euthanasia with Obama/Biden, I feel McCain/Palin have created stronger positions [and reasonings] for why they are pro-life.
Monday, October 20, 2008
McCain/Palin Position
After Obama stated his "biggest mistake" on the Terri Schiavo case, John McCain said he felt that her case was all "very sad" and a "great American tragedy." McCain's position on euthanasia and physician assisted suicide is easier to clarify than Obama's: McCain, as well as his running mate Sarah Palin, are very Republican and very pro-life. With that said, McCain and Palin are very firm believers in that every individual has the right to life, and practices including abortion and euthanasia, should not be considered in [majority] cases.
http://themaritimesentry.blogspot.com/2008/03/john-mccain-addresses-terri-schiavo.html
Although McCain has not firmly addressed his position on euthanasia and physician assisted suicide exactly, Republicans follow the principle that no human being should be considered the property of another. This principle explains why McCain did not agree with the decision made in the Terri Schiavo case. McCain would not agree that Terri's husband had the power and control to allow the doctors to proceed in the euthanasia, and McCain would not agree that doctors have the right to control the life or death of a patient. Majority of Republicans, including McCain and Palin, "uphold the principle that every human being, born and unborn, young and old, healthy and disabled, has a fundamental, individual right to life." If a broad statement needed to be made on McCain and Palin's position on euthanasia and physician assisted suicide, they would be against the practice's.
http://www.rnclife.org/brochure/rprolife.html
http://themaritimesentry.blogspot.com/2008/03/john-mccain-addresses-terri-schiavo.html
Although McCain has not firmly addressed his position on euthanasia and physician assisted suicide exactly, Republicans follow the principle that no human being should be considered the property of another. This principle explains why McCain did not agree with the decision made in the Terri Schiavo case. McCain would not agree that Terri's husband had the power and control to allow the doctors to proceed in the euthanasia, and McCain would not agree that doctors have the right to control the life or death of a patient. Majority of Republicans, including McCain and Palin, "uphold the principle that every human being, born and unborn, young and old, healthy and disabled, has a fundamental, individual right to life." If a broad statement needed to be made on McCain and Palin's position on euthanasia and physician assisted suicide, they would be against the practice's.
http://www.rnclife.org/brochure/rprolife.html
Obama/Biden Position
In 2005, there was much debate over whether Terri Schiavo should continue receiving a feeding tube to eat and drink (which would continue to keep her alive) or to stop issuing the feeding tube. With the feeding tube discontinued, doctor's knew Terri would not have much of a chance to live on her own. Terri's parents did not want the "euthanasia" to be issued, so they made an attempt to stop the process of discontinuing the feeding tube, and have the doctors continue giving their daughter food and water thru the tube (keeping Terri alive). Terri's husband argued that Terri had suffered long enough, and wanted to take his wife off the feeding tube, so she would not have to "suffer" anymore (she would die). Terri's husband also believed that he had the right to make the decision of whether or not Terri would be euthanised or not; he did not believe Terri's parents should be the one's to determine Terri's future. Senate agreed with Terri's husband, and "approved a compromise bill, which the House eventually supported on a lopsided bipartisan vote and President Bush signed, to help the disabled woman" (help being taking Terri off of the feeding tube). Barack Obama was one of the Senate members that voted with the Senate; he agreed that Terri's husband should be allowed to decide whether or not she would be kept on the feeding tube. Terri's husband had the doctor's remove the feeding tube, and after 14 days, Terri died from starvation and dehydration.
In a recent presidential debate, Obama argued that his "biggest mistake was voting with a unanimous Senate to help save Terri Schiavo" (again, help being taking Terri off the feeding tube). Obama stated that he was uncomfortable about the decision, and should have stood up and stopped it from happening. This is the second time [in a debate] Obama mentioned this "big mistake" he had made. However, Obama, as well as his running mate Joe Biden, follow the Democratic party in being "pro-choice" and although Terri Schiavo's case has been an exception to their beliefs, Obama/Biden generally believe that euthanasia and physician assisted suicide is acceptable (the patient-or relative of patient-makes the decision of life or death).
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1977276/posts
Obama and Biden, as well as majority of other Democrats, have been very pro-choice in decisions such as abortion, so it not a surprise that they would have similar feelings in decisions such as euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. Thus said, it is not a matter of being "for" or "against" euthanasia with Democrats, but more of a matter of allowing the person/patient to have the decision on what to do (whether it be to decide to have an abortion, or decide to be euthanised). Overall, Democrats including Obama and Biden, are the party of socialized medicine, a system that assumes the right of the state to meddle in health care decisions. If a broad statement needed to be made about Obama/Biden's position with the choice of euthanasia and physician assisted suicide, they would be for the right to allow these act's.
http://groups.google.com/group/soc.culture.usa/browse_thread/thread/271c93aaba48e21e
In a recent presidential debate, Obama argued that his "biggest mistake was voting with a unanimous Senate to help save Terri Schiavo" (again, help being taking Terri off the feeding tube). Obama stated that he was uncomfortable about the decision, and should have stood up and stopped it from happening. This is the second time [in a debate] Obama mentioned this "big mistake" he had made. However, Obama, as well as his running mate Joe Biden, follow the Democratic party in being "pro-choice" and although Terri Schiavo's case has been an exception to their beliefs, Obama/Biden generally believe that euthanasia and physician assisted suicide is acceptable (the patient-or relative of patient-makes the decision of life or death).
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1977276/posts
Obama and Biden, as well as majority of other Democrats, have been very pro-choice in decisions such as abortion, so it not a surprise that they would have similar feelings in decisions such as euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. Thus said, it is not a matter of being "for" or "against" euthanasia with Democrats, but more of a matter of allowing the person/patient to have the decision on what to do (whether it be to decide to have an abortion, or decide to be euthanised). Overall, Democrats including Obama and Biden, are the party of socialized medicine, a system that assumes the right of the state to meddle in health care decisions. If a broad statement needed to be made about Obama/Biden's position with the choice of euthanasia and physician assisted suicide, they would be for the right to allow these act's.
http://groups.google.com/group/soc.culture.usa/browse_thread/thread/271c93aaba48e21e
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
